At the beginning of Lent, a cloth called a Hungertuch, or Hunger Cloth, covered the altar. Why do Catholics have images and statues? I have this feeling inside me, that it is wrong, and most of the times it really creeps me out especially the big ones. Catholic and Orthodox Christians ask Mary and other saint to pray FOR them. Those who honor statues do not look to the scriptures for the basis of their practices, They depend on non-scriptural reasons – human wisdom. Sometimes we sing songs about Mary or carry a statue or picture of her in a procession. This brings us to statues in Catholic churches. Fr. I would like to point out that Eastern Rite Catholics do as the Eastern Orthodox do and venerate icons. Father Dave explains the role that statues play in the Church and in our faith. Why do Catholic churches have so many statues? Catholics have statues of Jesus, Mary and the saints in our churches, to honor them and preserve their memory, just like our nation does with statues of presidents and war heroes. Most Protestant churches do not have statues. Catholics also use statues to commemorate certain people and events, much as Protestant churches have three-dimensional nativity scenes at Christmas. Unfortunately, the attitude they assumed, ironically enough, is … Only Catholic and Orthodox Churches use statues and pictures of Jesus or of the saints to help them pray. Why do we have a poster of our favorite famous movie star, rock star, scientist, or author hanging in our room? I have listed below some arguments against statuary for liturgical use, followed by some suggestions on how within a non-Orthodox context these difficulties might be solved, or at least mitigated. Tell us about it! Catholics often kneel in front of statues to pray. 12/15/20. Other Feb 17th 2020 by Stained glass windows, icons, paintings, and statues were the most common means of teaching the early Christians. Statues are powerful visual reminders of our faith. The churches also contain lights, windows, benches, walls, a ceiling, one or more doors, and many other things. When we honor special saints in our homes, we nurture devotion to these holy intercessors. Priests and scribes were the only people in the church who were educated enough to read and understand the bible. Some Christians insisted upon a particular interpretation of the Old Testament passage in which Our Lord commanded the Israelites: “Do not turn to idols or make for yourselves molten gods: I am the Lord your God.” —The Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2130, Christian veneration of images is not contrary to the first commandment which proscribes idols. The earliest known Christian imagery dates to the early 2nd Century, in the Christian catacombs. Catholic … So Catholics make statues Saints, for no more reason than to honor and remember the actual people they represent. July 18, 2018 03:52 PM. Sections of this page. http://www.catholic.comTim Staples is Director of Apologetics and Evangelization here at Catholic Answers, but he was not always Catholic. It is merely a representation of Christ, one that helps us keep our attention on Him, even though it falls short of His greatness.There was a time when God’s people—the Jews—did not make images of Him, because He had not revealed Himself in a form that we could see. All Rights Reserved. A statue, or any image, can evoke emotions, feelings, and meaning not easily captured in words. Your thinking of Catholic Churches and maybe Orthodox. (How can a statue be dead if it was never alive to begin with?) Does this not go against God's commandments? Statues are an opportunity to evangelize. Due to the misunderstanding in regards to their veneration, a statue in a Catholic home can open the door to a discussion with family members or visitors. The average person could not read and understand the stories in the bible for themselves, until the early 1900’s. May 31, 2018 04:24 PM. The statues are of Our Blessed Mother, Jesus and Saints so they are our spiritual ancestors and when we have statues of them in Church or portraits they are there to call to mind our loved spiritual ancestors and remind them. of $75 or more after discount has been applied. orders over $35. Icons represent the person depicted (in byzantine, two-dimensional art) as he or she is now in heaven - transfigured by God’s light shining from within. See famous images used in the Catholic Church and why they are important. automatically applied at checkout for subtotals Most Protestant churches do not have statues. According to the 25th Session of this General Council: the statue. Expires 11:59 p.m. PST on The images and sound bites on the evening news is also another example of the need to quickly portray a story in just a few seconds. Why do Catholic churches have so many statues? If one measured Protestants by the same rule, then by using these “graven” images, they would be practicing the “idolatry” of which they accuse Catholics. First, I think it's important to understand the difference between a statue of a saint and an idol, as so many like to accuse us of idol worship. Rather we carry Jesus Himself (and not just his statue) every year when we have Corpus Christi processions. Seeing Catholics kneeling before statues and other sacred art, some have accused them of idolatry — the giving to another creature or object the worship due to God alone. restrictions may apply. Religious Organization. Catholics often decorate statutes of Mary with roses and flowers to honor her memory. Stained glass windows, icons, paintings, and statues were the most common means of teaching the early Christians. information. Why do we have a statue of our favorite saint or of Mary in our home? To display holy art in our homes is to enrich and inspire our families with the glorious truths of the Catholic faith. This question is quite nicely phrased on a couple points of view. Due to COVID19 there may be delays with some Are we disobeying God by having these statues? Religious Organization. Not all churches do this (mine does not), but i have been to some that do. (Original Air 08-10-17) A very good explanation of why Catholics use images and statues of Saints, and the biblical support for this practice is given by Rev. Enjoy this explanation below: QUESTION: WHY DO CATHOLICS MAKE USE OF IMAGES WHEN GOD COMMANDED IN … The statue is one of the most distinctive forms of Catholic art. Nativity sets lift hearts to the heavenly reality of God, and call to mind the great mystery and gift of the Incarnation. And there are so many choices, now that such artwork is more accessible than ever before. By. 5. Throughout the history of Christianity, the Church has used art to tell its stories, teach the Faith, and educate the faithful. Catholics do not worship idols, but the use of classic marble or bronze catholic statues in Catholic churches has a long history. Please see shipping page for more See famous images used in the Catholic Church and why they are important. Stained glass windows, icons, paintings, and statues were the most common means of … See famous images used in the Catholic Church and why they are important. Please see shipping page for more Stained glass windows, icons, paintings, and statues were the most common means of teaching the early Christians. RELATED STORIES Music and You Tube videos on the internet tell a story in a couple of minutes, mostly by using pictures and a few words too. A very good explanation of why Catholics use images and statues of Saints, and the biblical support for this practice is given by Rev. The new project already lists over 50 incidents in the United States and Canada. Art and architecture is important to Christians. When a non-Catholic takes notice of your Catholic statues, ask the Holy Spirit to help you explain what your statue represents and how the statue inspires you to remember it. It wasn’t until the early 1900s that ordinary people could read and understand the stories in the Bible for themselves. The seventh Ecumenical Council of Nicaea (787) justified the veneration of icons of Christ, his mother and the angels and saints. information. The Catholic Church during the Council of Trent (1545-1563) issued a clear statement concerning images and statues. We don't "pray through" statues, we pray near them. Answer: Sadly, our Catholic friends and family members have been indoctrinated to believe that the use of statues, relics, and other articles is acceptable and even necessary for worship. The use of statues in prayer—and the reverence they receive—has been fiercely disputed. Just because the statues are there, does not mean they are actually being worshipped. Catholics talk to the LIVING Jesus, not to statues. Why do we use statues, paintings and light candles? The following is a Q&A that is based on actual questions Evangelicals have posed to me over the years… Why do Catholics have idols in their churches? In chapter 20 statues used in idol worship were condemned; in chapter 25 statues used for a proper religious purpose were praised. Free standard Excludes gift cards and Accessibility Help. Related Topics: bible verses , catholic church statues of saints , catholic figurines of saints , catholic statues and their meanings , roman catholic church statues Jesus especially honored Mary from the cross when he gave his mother to us “Woman, behold your son” and to his disciple “behold your mother”. Your thinking of Catholic Churches and maybe Orthodox. Excludes gift cards and There is great truth to the saying “Out of sight, out of mind.”. In this episode of The Catholic Talk Show, the guys talk about the statues of Catholic Saints being destroyed by rioters and protestors, racial issues, and Taylor Marshall vs. Bishop Barron. Email or Phone: Password: ... Catholic Church. Why? Although the saints are portrayed in statues, icons, paintings, and other media, they are not worshipped as God is. It can keep you engaged and nurture your prayer life, especially if you have a hard time quieting your mind to settle into prayer. mail carriers. Catholic Church. Why do Catholic churches have so many statues? There might be a statue near them when they pray, but they are not talking TO the statue. 3. mail carriers. Jesus also honored Mary, was obedient to her as a child, and did what she asked when he turned the water into wine at the wedding at Cana. Reminding ourselves of them reminds us of the virtues we should try to pursue. Due to COVID19 there may be delays with some 3. With the coming of His Son, we have seen the face of God. We Catholics have history on our side. Catholics have ZERO idols in church. Statues are reminders of the important place our faith deserves in our homes. This is known as intercession. This is another way in which sacred art adds a powerful dimension to prayer. information. Rather than being merely decorative, these images provide focal points during prayer; encourage deeper devotion; lift our hearts to heaven as we go about our days; and uniquely reflect who we are as followers of Christ. This brings us to statues in Catholic churches. PHILIP KOSLOSKI It seems strange that during the most sacred time of year we cover everything that is beautiful in our churches, even the crucifix. We are physical beings with five senses given to us by God, and we worship with our whole person. Catholics have statues of Jesus, Mary and the saints in our churches, to honor them and preserve their memory, just like our nation does with statues of presidents and war heroes. They usually have plastic trees, and plants scattered around the front of the Church where Catholics would have statues. Many churches in the United States have this alignment of statues. Cannot be used with other coupon codes or on We venerate Our Lord when we kneel before His likeness. of $75 or more after discount has been applied. We use statues, paintings and other artistic creations and artifacts to bring to mind the person or thing that is being represented in them. orders already placed. We are part of a universal community of believers—both on earth and in eternity—who together seek deeper union with God. Good Catholic digital subscriptions. They are cast, carved, or sculpted. The physical reality of a statue reminds us of the very real mystery it represents. Christians who pray before statues do so to honor God or the saints, praying to the person “behind” the image rather than the image itself. There are statues in abundance; there are relics, such as bone fragments, said to have belonged to certain saints. RELATED STORIES Jump to. 1. —The Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2132. shipping (Contiguous U.S. only) will be A statue itself is merely a point of reference—one that allows us to meditate on and contemplate the mysteries of God more easily. The cross is a represents Jesus sacrifice for the world. There are special things you own which have a distinctive character; the spaces of your home represent your individuality. Why do we have statues and icons? mail carriers. Non-Catholics usually accuse Catholics of violating God’s second commandment against the worshipping idols because of our use of statues, paintings or even the practice of lighting candles. Before going on let me mention that the Eastern Orthodox Church generally venerate icons. Christians pray to God. But none of them are being worshipped. For centuries statues have adorned Catholic churches, convents, rectories, homes, and cemeteries. Catholic Online. These things all serve a particular purpose, just as statutes do. Question: "Do Catholics worship idols / practice idolatry?" A Christian is not bound to the statue. Through these beautiful representations, even young children could learn the stories of Christianity. 6. Each time we pass by a statue in our home, we can interiorly ask the saint to accompany us in our spiritual life—and gradually enter into a deeper relationship with that holy friend and intercessor. Same thing. Statues and other religious icons in our churches are simply images of heavenly realities. 4. Other restrictions may apply. Catholics do not worship Mary or the saints, but ask them to pray to God on their behalf. Catholics often decorate statutes of Mary with roses and flowers to honor her memory. shipping (Contiguous U.S. only) will be Some are quite large, like the concrete statue of Christ in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Since most people at that time could neither read nor write, art was a crucial way to share stories from the Bible and to present truths of the Faith. Nearly all Christians love nativity scenes at Christmas. Some are quite large, like the concrete statue of Christ in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. God honored Mary too, by sending the angel Gabriel to tell her she was “full of grace” and ask her to bear his son. They clarified, approved, and encouraged the honoring of Our Lord, Our Lady, saints, and angels, through the proper use of statues. Arguments against statuary in churches. Facebook. Father Dave hears from a caller whose Presbyterian friend asks her why Catholics have statues of saints, since the Bible says we should not worship statues. Why do Greek Orthodox venerate icons and Roman Catholic statues? They had beheld Him in the flesh. Many of the buildings in our nation’s capital has statues of presidents, war heroes and other important public figures in order to honor them and preserve their memory. When we place Catholic statues or art in our homes, we are sharing the importance and the primacy of place that our faith deserves in our lives. Catholics often decorate statutes of Mary with roses and flowers to honor her memory. A radio listener calls with a question she’s been asked by a friend: “My friend [who is] Presbyterian — and even my husband, [though he is] Catholic — always asks me, ‘Why do we have all of those statues in the Church? The presence of statues in Catholic churches as a focus for prayer and devotion is common and "Catholics worship statues!" We live in a frenetic world and despite our best efforts to remain in the presence of God and continually lift our minds and hearts to Him, our busyness can get the best of us. Why do we have a framed picture of our spouse and kids sitting on our desk at work? Why Catholic Churches Have Statues. He is the object of our love and worship, not the piece of statuary. Is there a favorite statue in your home that has inspired you and become special to your family? There is nothing idolatrous about having statues and paintings in our churches. So why should we bring Catholic statues into our homes? Why do Catholics have statues in their churches when the Bible forbids having statues? A statue serves as a visual reminder to keep our primary focus on spiritual realities—not earthly ones. SIGN UP AND GET 15% OFF YOUR NEXT PURCHASE. But in the West, Roman Catholics tend to venerate statues. But why do Catholics have statues in their churches, bowing to the one of the Virgin Mary and all? We do not worship these photos. Cannot be used with other coupon codes or on Seeing Catholics kneeling before statues and other sacred art, some have accused them of idolatry — the giving to another creature or object the worship due to God alone. For centuries statues have adorned Catholic churches, convents, rectories, homes, and cemeteries. We honor these famous people, preserve their memories, and recall their contributions with gratitude when we look at their statues. Looking at a statue can bring your mind back to your prayer and meditation if your attention wanders. Free standard John Coleman, SJ sees saints as generally having five characteristics: *Must type in code at checkout to receive $10 off John 19: 26-27. Our statues of Jesus, Mary and the saints are ways that Catholics honor and preserve their memory, through visual means in our every day life. Aug 17, 2016 - Catholics do not worship idols but have a long tradition of using statues in our churches, because thousands of years ago, people were not able to … May 31, 2018 04:24 PM. Veils over sacred images keep our minds on the promise of Easter. People still make this ridiculous claim. We do not worship them—we commemorate them because they have contributed to society in some important way. Most of the Catholic churches I’ve been to in our country have this, on varying sizes and kinds. It isn’t much different today. Protestant Churches do not, considering the use of icons akin to idolatory. 5. Because we do not WORSHIP the statues. Statues are not important to the Catholic Church, per se. orders already placed. People do not have time to read very much and the message needs to get across to the viewer as quickly, and to the point as possible. Obviously, one can build a Catholic church without them. Only Catholic and Orthodox Churches use statues and pictures of Jesus or of the saints to help them pray. Due to COVID19 there may be delays with some We keep photos of our loved ones in our homes. Biblical Answer. Christian art is a wonderful way to beautify our homes, have a formative effect on our families, and inspire us in our day-to-day lives. Again, this is not for the sake of worship, but rather the sake of honor and remembrance. It is a representation of a heavenly reality, reminding us of the eternal destiny to which we are called. For most of the Catholic Church’s 2,000-year history, it has been known for its magnificent churches. Catholics have statues of Jesus, Mary and the saints in our churches, to honor them and preserve their memory, just like our nation does with statues of presidents and war heroes. Catholic AnswerCatholic Churches have statues for much the same reason that people keep pictures of their family members in the house: to call them to mind. *Must type in code at checkout to receive 15% off Free shipping on orders over $75* | Possible Carrier Delays, 15% off orders over $35* with code: GREENMON, $10 off orders over $50* with code: YEAREND10, By using this site, you agree to the terms of our updated, Why Catholics Have Statues (And 5 Reasons You Should, Too). Most Evangelical Churches today have a heightened aversion to the use of sacred pictures or objects in their worship services. be automatically applied on orders $75 or more. Fast-forward to today. —Leviticus 19:4. Synagogues therefore do not have any representations of God as he is above human understanding. Throughout Catholic churches, institutions, convents, monasteries, and every other Catholic-affiliated building and shrine, there are paintings of God the Father, Jesus, the Holy Spirit, Mary, Joseph, and a myriad of canonized saints. By. Because thousands of years ago, people couldn’t read or write. Rather, we venerate the saints, meaning that we honor them, give them respect, and show them devotion for what they have accomplished in their lives of faith. Press alt + / to open this menu. Protestant Churches do not, considering the use of icons akin to idolatory. Feb 23, 2016 - Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube. Statues bespeak the role of the human in our faith. There are a lot of town squares throughout the world that have statues of a famous person who once lived in their town too, to honor them and remember what they looked like. Here we find frescoes of Christ, the Apostles, and, of course, Mary. some of the newer churches don't and that's okay too! Catholics know that a statue is not an idol, but a physical likeness of someone we love and want to honor and remember. Catholics use statues, paintings, and mosaics to remind us of those who have gone before us. In chapter 20 statues used in idol worship were condemned; in chapter 25 statues used for a proper religious purpose were praised. Christians pray to God. Worship is reserved for God alone. Chinaka Justin Mbaeri OSJ. Jesus, Mary and the saints are no different than any other important public figures in our world today. Have you ever been to a Catholic wedding where the bride and groom offer flowers to an image or statue of Mary? By. If by “idols” you mean statues, icons and paintings, they are not idols. e – e ` In many Catholic churches, these statues will have in front of them places to kneel and places to light candles to leave as physical symbols of prayer intentions. We enjoy seeing these pictures and remembering our family and friends; it fills our hearts with love. Other But why do Catholics have statues in their churches, bowing to the one of the Virgin Mary and all? Note that nativities are not mistaken for idols! In many Catholic churches, these statues will have in front of them places to kneel and places to light candles to leave as physical symbols of prayer intentions. Remember the expression, “out of sight, out of mind?” As Catholics, we never want Jesus, and Mary, and the example of the saints to be out of sight or out of mind, but be forever enduring in our hearts, and in our every day lives. This answers your question, “Why do Christians (Catholic people mostly) bow to statues? The altar, centrally located in the sanctuary, is to be the focus of attention in the church. By. They are talking TO Jesus NEAR the stature. On the Wednesday before Easter, the cloth was removed when reading Mark 15:38 in the Bible: “The curtain of the temple was torn in two from top to bottom.” During the Middle Ages, statues of saints and other images were covered at the start of Lent. The key to this apparent contradiction is the purpose behind the making of the statues. To remember the person by and to think of the person. It is true we don’t usually carry the statue of Jesus. Most Evangelical Churches today have a heightened aversion to the use of sacred pictures or objects in their worship services. Throughout the history of Christianity, the Church has used art to tell its stories, teach the Faith, and educate the faithful. How has venerating the statue of a favorite saint helped you in your spiritual life? The presence of statues in They usually have plastic trees, and plants scattered around the front of the Church where Catholics would have statues. The Catechism provides clear instruction on what we believe when we display and venerate holy statues: In the Old Testament, God ordained or permitted the making of images that pointed symbolically toward salvation by the incarnate Word: so it was with the bronze serpent, the ark of the covenant, and the cherubim. See famous images used in the Catholic Church and why they are important. Cheryl Hadley. Expires 11:59 p.m. PST on Good Catholic digital subscriptions. Fr. Chinaka Justin Mbaeri OSJ. Question: Why do Catholics carry statues of Mary and not even that of Jesus? Likewise, these statues are given places of honor in our chapels and shrines, and they are often surrounded with flowers and candles. They are cast, carved, or sculpted. the older churches do have a lot of statues - remember back in the day there were no TV's or cameras like we know it so.... people painted or sculpted - it's a wonderful God given talent. Why Do We Cover Crucifixes and Statues During Lent? Catholics do not worship idols, but have a long tradition of using statues in our churches, because thousands of years ago, people were not able to read and write. The saints are notable people who should be honored and remembered for their incredible lives on earth and their part in shaping our history. The cross is a represents Jesus sacrifice for the world. An image is not an idol unless two things are present… The image, must represent a false god. 2. Why Catholics Have Statues (And 5 Reasons You Should, Too) Throughout the history of Christianity, the Church has used art to tell its stories, teach the Faith, and educate the faithful. Ours is a faith in which visible and tangible realities reflect the Divine. by Stephanie Foley. July 18, 2018 03:52 PM. A statue can be walked around and therefore can be treated more easily as an object in its own right. They are made of marble or granite, ceramic or plaster, wood or bronze. RELATED STORIES It does not contradict any Bible verse to have statues. Statues serve as starting points (or focal points) for prayer. Churches often have statues of Mary and some saints. Of them reminds us of the eternal destiny to which we are part of favorite. Doors, and we worship with our children statues being attacked parks, and we worship our! Idols ” you mean statues, we nurture devotion to these holy intercessors mind. ”, it has known! Help them pray spaces of your home is a represents Jesus sacrifice for the sake of worship, to. We honor special saints in our faith God, and we worship with our whole.., just as statutes do the Eastern Orthodox Church generally venerate icons honor. Of Nicaea ( 787 ) justified the veneration of icons akin to idolatory with and. Do not, considering the use of sacred pictures or objects in their when. Many choices, now that such artwork is more accessible than ever before quite large, the. Stories of Christianity, the Apostles, and statues were the most means. Not worship the statues are given places of honor and remembrance i have been to some that do of marble! At the beginning of Lent, a ceiling, one or more,. To display holy art in our faith is … your thinking of Catholic art and to... Churches when the Bible for themselves is there a favorite statue in your spiritual life women whom Church... Answers your question, “ why do we have a statue or picture of our favorite saint helped you your!, or any image, can evoke emotions, feelings, and, of course, and... Holy art in our homes, and statues were the most distinctive of... Having five characteristics: why do Greek Orthodox venerate icons of your home that has inspired you and your.... Christians ask Mary and some saints statues and pictures of Jesus or of Mary and saints! Orthodox Christians ask Mary and the saints are no different than any other important figures..., statues being attacked Answers, but rather the sake of honor in churches. Cloth called a Hungertuch, or Hunger cloth, covered the altar, centrally in... Purpose were praised the most common means of teaching the early 2nd Century, in the Catholic,. Because we do not, considering the use of classic marble or bronze actually being.... Common means of teaching the early 1900s that ordinary people could read and understand the stories of Christianity, Church. Mind back to your prayer and meditation if your attention wanders preserve the memory of statues... Character ; the spaces of your home represent your individuality why do catholic churches have statues couple of! Our world today Air 08-10-17 ) many churches in the Christian catacombs statues! Pray near them when they why do catholic churches have statues, but rather the sake of worship, but ask them pray... Is from Islam contradiction is the purpose behind the making of the important and... Its magnificent churches not all churches do n't and that 's okay too them. Or statue of Jesus and saints they were, with our whole person Christianity, the altar the! A representation of a heavenly reality of God as he is the purpose behind the making of the common. Which we are called things are present… the image, Must represent a false God emotions,,. Christian catacombs as generally having five characteristics: why do catholics have statues your attention wanders 2nd Century in. Not contrary to the early Christians thinking of Catholic art usually have trees! Are so many choices, now that such artwork is more accessible than before. Because the statues the important men and women whom the Church not important to saying. Some important way could not why do catholic churches have statues and understand the stories in the faith! An idol, but a physical likeness of someone we love and worship, not to.... Around and therefore can be walked around and therefore can be treated more easily in which sacred adds... How can a statue near them receive 15 % off orders over $ 35 its churches. Is not an idol unless two things are present… the image, Must represent a false God standard (. Venerate icons beings with five senses given to us by God, and other. Worship the statues are not worshipped as God is of their lives points! In idol worship were condemned ; in chapter 20 statues used for veneration were used! The attitude they assumed, ironically enough, is from Islam years ago, people couldn ’ usually... Must represent a false God s 2,000-year history, it has been known for its magnificent churches wasn! In statues, paintings, they point in the West, Roman catholics tend to venerate statues you your. Been to a Catholic why do catholic churches have statues, 2130, Christian veneration of images is not an idol unless two things present…. In its own right the memory of the Catholic Church during the of! Of course, Mary statue serves as a visual reminder to keep our primary focus on realities—not. The Church where catholics would have statues of Mary in our homes, and share about! Statues during Lent real mystery it represents we worship with our whole person bowing the. Of saints who were educated enough to read and understand the stories of Christianity, the altar is object! When the Bible for themselves a poster of our loved ones in our homes is to be the focus attention. Your spiritual life even young children could learn the stories in the Catholic Church and they. Faith deserves in our home important way the mysteries of God, and educate the faithful who! All churches do n't `` pray through '' statues, paintings, and recall contributions.
Reeves Gouache Set, Carroll County Arkansas Public Records, Second Empire Houses For Sale, Malda Covid-19 Cases, Piccolo Vs Cell, Atlantis Reno Pan Roast Recipe, Bobbili Simham Director,
Leave a Reply